Renewing Literature Reviews in MIS Research? A Critical Realist Approach
de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Mitev, Nathalie; Smith, Matthew; Walsh, Isabelle (2014), Renewing Literature Reviews in MIS Research? A Critical Realist Approach. https://basepub.dauphine.fr/handle/123456789/13056
TypeDocument de travail / Working paper
Series titleCahier de recherche DRM
MetadataShow full item record
Author(s)de Vaujany, François-Xavier
Dauphine Recherches en Management [DRM]
Department of Management - London School of Economics and Political Science [LSE]
Abstract (EN)Literature Reviews (LR) are particularly useful for demonstrating the coherence and cumulativeness (or lack thereof) of MIS research and for developing avenues for further research. Most top-tier journals now publish LRs, and many have even begun devoting specific sections to them. Our starting point is that LRs are not epistemologically neutral, and three approaches commonly underlie literature reviews: positivism (identifying the concepts, theories and models closest to the phenomenon that is being explained); interpretivism (identifying the various concepts and theories expressed by various actors and grouping them into multiple perspectives); and critical approaches (identifying both the underlying assumptions and conditions of the production of theories and their effects). We suggest a fourth approach to LRs underpinned by the philosophy of critical realism (CR) and argue that it can enable the (re)interpretation of existing literature through the identification of underlying generative mechanisms. These generative mechanisms provide a common denominator to enable the synthesis of concepts and theories in new ways, helping to bridge previously thought to be incompatible theories, and contributing to a more cumulative view of academic knowledge. We illustrate the value of a CR-based literature through its application to the topic of IT Strategic Value in the MIS and strategic management literature; we show how the identification of four generative mechanisms and three core agencies can support a more integrated view of IT Strategic Value. We then discuss the implications of the use of generative mechanisms and propose guidelines from a CR perspective for carrying out literature reviews.
Subjects / KeywordsInformation Technology (IT); critical realism; Literature review; generative mechanism; strategic value
Showing items related by title and author.
Developing theoretical contributions in IS research: a focus on revision processes in top-tier journals Organizations de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Mitev, Nathalie; Walsh, Isabelle (2011) Communication / Conférence
Applying and theorizing institutional frameworks in IS research: a systematic comparison from 1999 to 2009 Carton, Sabine; de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Mitev, Nathalie; Romeyer, Cécile (2014) Article accepté pour publication ou publié